Part 1. After a decent run in the early ’90s the draft selections were just starting to deteriorate when we left off. Today we look delve into the decisions that made the Lions a yearly threat for a top five pick. The last edition saw two guys who played 12 years with Detroit and had Pro-Bowl seasons. This edition has but one player that you can make an argument that he wasn’t a bust. Here is your roster of big time busts:
Aaron Gibson, OL, Wisconsin, 1999: An All-American season with the Badgers led to the Lions selecting the fattest player in the history of the NFL, weighing in at 410 lbs. Not surprisingly, he didn’t work out. After two seasons the Fat Tub took his lard to Dallas, and then Chicago…and then Austin. That’s Austin of the Arena Football League. With the league folding this year, Gibson needs to reevaluate his life choices.
Chris Claiborne, LB, USC, 1999: Detroit took Claiborne ninth, ahead of a slew of players who eventually found themselves in a Lions’ uniform including Daunte Culpepper, Damien Woody and Fernando Bryant. His career started off ok with four years of 50+ tackles. He then decided he was too cool for the Lions and signed with Minnesota where they moved him to the outside. After one more decent season, he steadily declined and was last seen with the Giants, making 1 tackle the whole season. He is still holding onto the dream and has not retired but we all know his career is over.
Stockar McDougle, OL, Oklahoma, 2000: The first pick of the new century was the one with the best name. McDougle went 20th overall and was supposed to anchor the line for years to come at left tackle. After starting 11 games in two years, he was moved to the right side. He impressed so much that the team let him walk after five years of service. He went to Miami and then Jacksonville but hasn’t been an NFL roster since the 2007 season. Like Claiborne, he is still living the dream and has not retired.
Jeff Backus, OL, Michigan, 2001: Probably the only success story still on the board, Backus came to Detroit because of the 18th pick. Despite some question as to whether he is good it hasn’t stopped him from started every single game for the Lions since that fateful day when he was cursed forever.
Joey Harrington, QB, Oregon, 2002: Now it gets fun. Joey Heisman came over to Detroit with the 3rd overall pick. He got everything started by discussing the correct pronunciation of Oregon and saying all the right things. Then we saw the true side of him. On one of the Lions only non-Thanksgiving day national broadcast, he played the piano, ate strawberries and wine and had an irregular heartbeat. Needless to say, he couldn’t handle the city and was traded for a sixth round pick. Basically the Lions trade #3 overall for some in the 180s overall, great move. Harrington went to Miami and lost the only chance he had to start to Cleo Lemon. He then moved to Atlanta, where he last appeared in an NFL regular season game, which only happened because Michael Vick got injured. He is now 14th on the depth chart in New Orleans and lives every day in fear of getting cut. His career stats look like: 26-50, 79 TDs, 85 INTs, 14693 yards with a 69.4 QB rating.
Charles Rogers, WR, Michigan State, 2003: The 2003 NCAA National Championship changed Rogers and the Lions’ Franchise forever. Willis McGahee took caught a simple screen pass and took a hit that destroyed every ligament in his knee. McGahee was supposed to be the #2 pick. That honor went to Rogers who became one of the biggest busts in the NFL (Andre Johnson went a pick later). After a solid 8 games in his rookie season, Rogers broke his collarbone. He then started smoking weed hardcore, broke the same collarbone in the next game he played and then kept smoking weed and added prescription drugs to arsenal. His 440 yards and 4 TDs in three years are the only numbers he has put up in the NFL. Since then he has gotten arrested and had seven kids with two different women. One more and he gets the group discount at Disney World. He also appeared on Outside the Lines in a story that goes from sad to kind of funny in a span of about 4.3 seconds. Between hearing a man with a college education say “yeah, I blew ayeday, I blew ayeday,” and watching Matt Millen get another chance at trying to explain himself you can’t help but laugh. How fast did Millen accept the offer? “Hey Matt, we’re doing a story for Outside t–,” ”I’m in! It’s in front of a camera right?” At 28 Rogers is looking for a return to the NFL but, no one is going to take him if he is blowing ayeday.
Kevin Jones, RB, Virginia Tech, 2004: The Lions liked Jones’ 1647 yard final season at Va. Tech so much that they traded up to get him. Early on he was spectacular, rushing for 1,000 yards in his first season. However, after I used a second round pick in my fantasy draft the following year to get him, his career went downhill. As his yardage went down, his touchdowns actually went up. In his final year with Detroit, he had only 581 yards, but 8 TDs. That performance was not good enough to keep him on the team and Jones signed with Chicago following that 2007 season. He spent last year as a backup to Matt Forte and will continue that role this year.
Roy Williams, WR, Texas, 2004: Williams’ 4.36 40 yard dash earned him the 7th overall pick in that same 2004 draft that led to Kevin Jones as well. He was supposed to be the second half of a receiver duo that was going to be around for years. That didn’t work out so well. Williams put up a solid 4.5 years with Detroit, recording 4,314 yards and 31 TDs and one Pro Bowl appearance. During the tail end of his stint here, he realized he was going to enter free agency Lions and just stopped working out. Instead of letting just him walk Detroit involved him in arguably the greatest trade in the history of the Lions franchise. Roy Williams and a 7th round pick for, get this: a 1st, 3rd, and 6th. In other words Roy Williams cost more to acquire than Brett Favre. Those picks turned into Brandon Pettigrew, Derrick Williams and Third String Hero Aaron Brown. Not a bad haul for someone who was going to leave anyway.
Mike Williams, WR, USC, 2005: After following everybody’s role model Maurice Clarett into the draft, Williams was forced to sit out a year after the ruling was overturned. The Lions didn’t shy away and made him the third WR to be selected with their first pick in three consecutive years. Rogers, Williams and Williams on the field at the same time! Think about the matchup problems! Mel Kiper loved it. Turned out Williams didn’t know how to run a route and was 270 pounds. He played just 2 measly years with my favorite team and recorded 2 TDs and 449 yards. He played 2007 with Oakland and Tennessee and is attempting a comeback. Ha ha! Oh that’s not a joke.
As for the three recent first round picks Ernie Sims, Calvin Johnson, and Gosder Cherilus you probably know about them. They are still on the team and it is too early to decide whether they are busts.
Quick Recap: 0 Hall of Famers, 2-3 Pro-Bowl players and only one player that was selected 1st Team All-Pro while with the Lions. Not counting the last three 1st picks prior to this year, the Lions have had 18 picks that average 5.4 years with the team. Not exactly cornerstones of the franchise. The good news is the last three picks look good. Stafford and Pettigrew, the two first round picks this year, have played one and zero games respectively. Just a bit too early to tell. With the Lions history, they literally have no expectations to live up to. There is always good news.